Used Cars near Middletown, NY - Vehicles Under $10,000

Visit Johnstons Toyota to Find Used Cars for Sale at a Quality Price

At Johnstons Toyota, we want to make sure each customer finds their dream car, and most importantly, something that fits their lifestyle, meets their needs, and matches their budget.  In our under $10,000 bargain vehicle category, we have an excellent selection of used cars to choose from for an unbeatable price. Choose from a variety of makes and models. Any of these used cars for sale are perfect for Middletown, Scotchtown, Newburgh, Goshen, Warwick, and Monroe, New York roads.

Show Only

Keyword

9 Vehicles matching:
  • All Listings
  • Page 1 of 1
  • 2010 Toyota Prius III Hatchback

    • Market Price :$9,577
    • Savings:$1,180
    • Our Price:$8,397
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    133,995 miles,
    MPG Range:
    51/48,
    Engine:
    1.8L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Variable,
    Drive Line:
    FWD,
    Exterior Color:
    Sandy Beach,
    Interior Color:
    Tan,
    Stock #:
    60375
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
    • Maintenance
    • Comments Featuring a push button start, braking assist, stability control, traction control, anti-lock brakes, dual airbags, side air bag system, and airbag de...
  • 2013 Subaru Forester 2.5X w/Alloy Wheel Pkg SUV

    • Market Price :$9,977
    • Savings:$1,004
    • Our Price:$8,973
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    131,749 miles,
    MPG Range:
    21/27,
    Engine:
    2.5L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Drive Line:
    AWD,
    Exterior Color:
    Satin White Pearl,
    Interior Color:
    Platinum,
    Stock #:
    52191
    More
    Alloy Wheel Value Package (Wheels: 16" x 6.5JJ Aluminum Alloy, Black Roof Rails)
    • Carfax Free
    • Maintenance
    • Comments If you're looking for a smooth ride, look no further than this 2013 Subaru Forester 2.5X with a braking assist, stability control, traction control, a...
  • 2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium w/All-Weather Pkg SUV

    • Market Price :$10,977
    • Savings:$990
    • Our Price:$9,987
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    107,229 miles,
    MPG Range:
    21/27,
    Engine:
    2.5L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Drive Line:
    AWD,
    Exterior Color:
    Marine Blue Pearl,
    Interior Color:
    Black,
    Stock #:
    60045
    More
    All-Weather Package (Heated Exterior Mirrors, Heated Front Seats, Windshield Wiper De-Icer)
    • Carfax One Owner
    • Maintenance
    • Comments This 2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium is a great option for folks looking for top features like a braking assist, stability control, traction control...
  • 2012 Honda Civic LX Sedan

    • Market Price :$8,977
    • Savings:$988
    • Our Price:$7,989
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    107,374 miles,
    MPG Range:
    28/39,
    Engine:
    1.8L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Drive Line:
    FWD,
    Exterior Color:
    Gray,
    Interior Color:
    Gray,
    Stock #:
    60072
    More
    • Carfax Free
    • Maintenance
    • Comments This GRAY 2012 Honda Civic LX might be just the sedan for you. This one's a deal at $7,989. For a good-looking vehicle from the inside out, this car...
  • 2014 Subaru XV Crosstrek SUV

    • Market Price :$12,489
    • Savings:$2,500
    • Our Price:$9,989
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    126,739 miles,
    MPG Range:
    29/33,
    Engine:
    2.0L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Variable,
    Drive Line:
    AWD,
    Exterior Color:
    Satin White Pearl,
    Interior Color:
    Ivory,
    Stock #:
    60191
    More
    Popular Package #1 (Auto Dimming Mirror w/Compass, Rear Bumper Cover, Matte Black Splash Guards, All Weather Floor Mats, )
    • Carfax One Owner
    • Maintenance
    • Comments Auto fans love the push button start, braking assist, a power outlet, hill start assist, stability control, traction control, anti-lock brakes, dual a...
  • 2012 Jeep Patriot Latitude 4x4 SUV

    • Market Price :$10,977
    • Savings:$1,010
    • Our Price:$9,967
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    91,542 miles,
    MPG Range:
    21/26,
    Engine:
    2.4L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Variable,
    Drive Line:
    4WD,
    Exterior Color:
    Black,
    Interior Color:
    Dark Slate Gray,
    Stock #:
    60222
    More
    Sun/Sound Group, Security and Cargo Convenience Group, Radio: Media Center 430 CD/DVD/MP3/HDD, Uconnect Voice Command w/Bluetooth, (more packages)
    • Carfax One Owner
    • Maintenance
    • Comments This BLACK 2012 Jeep Patriot Latitude might be just the SUV 4X4 for you. This one's a deal at $9,967. It has a sharp black exterior and a black inte...
  • 2011 GMC Canyon Work Truck Truck Regular Cab

    • Market Price :$10,977
    • Savings:$1,010
    • Our Price:$9,967
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    76,720 miles,
    MPG Range:
    17/23,
    Engine:
    2.9L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Drive Line:
    4WD,
    Exterior Color:
    Steel Green,
    Interior Color:
    Ebony,
    Stock #:
    60267
    More
    Trailering Equipment (Trailer Hitch, 7-Pin Sealed Trailer Wiring Connector)
    • Carfax Free
    • Maintenance
    • Comments This GRAY 2011 GMC Canyon Work Truck might be just the regular cab 4x4 for you. This one's available at the low price of $9,967. A gorgeous gray ext...
  • 2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Sedan

    • Market Price :$10,977
    • Savings:$998
    • Our Price:$9,979
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    94,479 miles,
    MPG Range:
    21/28,
    Engine:
    2.5L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Manual,
    Drive Line:
    AWD,
    Exterior Color:
    Ice Silver,
    Interior Color:
    Black Striated,
    Stock #:
    60363
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
    • Maintenance
    • Comments This SILVER 2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i might be just the sedan awd for you. This one's on the market for $9,979. A beautiful silver exterior and a blac...
  • 2015 Ford Focus SE Sedan

    • Market Price:$9,977
    • Savings:$1,010
    • Our Price:$8,967
    • Get Johnstons Price
    • Send to Phone
    Mileage:
    66,625 miles,
    MPG Range:
    26/36,
    Engine:
    2.0L i-4,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Drive Line:
    FWD,
    Exterior Color:
    Tuxedo Black,
    Interior Color:
    Black,
    Stock #:
    60414
    More
    • Carfax Free
    • Maintenance
    • Comments People everywhere will love the way this 2015 Ford Focus SE drives with features like a braking assist, stability control, traction control, anti-lock...
  • Page 1 of 1

Middletown, Scotchtown, Newburgh & Monroe Drivers Know They're Getting a Good Deal

Each model is carefully inspected for safety and dependability. And the staff at Johnstons Toyota used car dealership has got you covered. Our finance department is happy to assist you with applying for financing and securing a loan.

Used cars are always inspected from the top to the bottom before they're traded into Johnstons Toyota used car dealership, which means you will always drive away with a safe and dependable vehicle. Another reason why previously owned cars are a good investment is simple. The biggest depreciation hit has already been taken. This is because a new car diminishes in value by 20-percent the minute it's driven off the lot, and another 10-percent is lost the first year someone owns it.

A used car is also a contender because drivers usually get more luxury features without spending as much money. This is because a base model of a new car will be more money than a used car from the bargain inventory segment. Your monthly insurance costs may also dwindle if you purchase a used vehicle. This is because it's worth can impact your monthly rate, and a used car costs less than a new vehicle, which means it will not be thought of as more valuable.

The best part is that once you decide on your next dream car, our certified automotive mechanics can help with routine maintenance like oil changes, tire rotations, and brake inspections. We want to make sure your next car is faithful, reliable and built to last.

Take a minute to browse our online inventory. If you find something you like, stop by Johnstons Toyota so one of our experienced sales associates can help you test-drive your next dream car. Then our finance specialists will walk you through the process, and you'll be on your way. We proudly serve drivers in Middletown, Goshen, Warwick, and beyond.


*The advertised price does not include sales tax, vehicle registration fees, finance charges, documentation charges ($75), and any other fees required by law. We attempt to update this inventory on a regular basis. However, there can be lag time between the sale of a vehicle and the update of the inventory.


; ;