Used Cars near Middletown, NY - Vehicles Under $10,000

Visit Johnstons Toyota to Find Used Cars for Sale at a Quality Price

At Johnstons Toyota, we want to make sure each customer finds their dream car, and most importantly, something that fits their lifestyle, meets their needs, and matches their budget.  In our under $10,000 bargain vehicle category, we have an excellent selection of used cars to choose from for an unbeatable price. Choose from a variety of makes and models. Any of these used cars for sale are perfect for Middletown, Scotchtown, Newburgh, Goshen, Warwick, and Monroe, New York roads.

Show Only

Keyword

15 Vehicles matching:
  • All Listings
  • Page 1 of 1
  • 2010 Toyota Corolla XLE Sedan Front-wheel Drive

    • MSRP:$9,977
    • Dealer Discount:$1,599
    • Market Price:$8,378
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.8L I-4 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    106,437 miles,
    MPG Range:
    26/34,
    Exterior Color:
    Super White,
    Interior Color:
    FC40,
    Stock #:
    42568
    More
    • Carfax Free
  • 2012 Toyota Corolla S Sedan Front-wheel Drive

    • MSRP:$11,477
    • Dealer Discount:$1,488
    • Market Price:$9,989
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.8L I-4 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    94,514 miles,
    MPG Range:
    26/34,
    Exterior Color:
    Black Sand Pearl,
    Interior Color:
    Dark Charcoal,
    Stock #:
    42559
    More
    • Carfax Free
  • 2005 Scion xA Base Sedan Front-wheel Drive

    • MSRP:$6,577
    • Dealer Discount:$1,294
    • Market Price:$5,283
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.5L I-4 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    79,225 miles,
    MPG Range:
    31/38,
    Exterior Color:
    Phantom Gray Pearl,
    Stock #:
    42481
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2006 Scion xA Base Hatchback Front-wheel Drive

    • Market Price:$6,283
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.5L I-4 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    65,066 miles,
    MPG Range:
    31/38,
    Exterior Color:
    Salsa Red Pearl,
    Interior Color:
    Dark Charcoal,
    Stock #:
    42446
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2011 Subaru Impreza 2.5i Premium 4dr Sedan All-wheel Drive

    • Market Price:$7,683
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    2.5L H-4 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    117,844 miles,
    MPG Range:
    20/26,
    Exterior Color:
    Blue,
    Stock #:
    42415
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2009 Honda Accord 2.4 LX-P Sedan Front-wheel Drive

    • Market Price:$7,988
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    2.4L I-4 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    140,443 miles,
    MPG Range:
    21/30,
    Exterior Color:
    Gray,
    Stock #:
    42517
    More
    • Carfax Free
  • 2009 Nissan Rogue SUV All-wheel Drive

    • Market Price:$8,483
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    2.5L I-4 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    82,031 miles,
    MPG Range:
    21/26,
    Exterior Color:
    Gotham Gray,
    Stock #:
    42387
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2011 Honda Accord 2.4 SE Sedan Front-wheel Drive

    • MSRP:$10,477
    • Dealer Discount:$1,510
    • Market Price:$8,967
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    2.4L I-4 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    107,550 miles,
    MPG Range:
    23/34,
    Exterior Color:
    Black,
    Stock #:
    42583
    More
    • Carfax Free
  • 2006 Volkswagen New Beetle 2.5 Convertible Front-wheel Drive

    • MSRP:$10,477
    • Dealer Discount:$1,504
    • Market Price:$8,973
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    2.5L I-5 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    44,271 miles,
    MPG Range:
    22/30,
    Exterior Color:
    White,
    Stock #:
    42555
    More
    • Carfax Free
  • 2004 Ford Mustang Coupe Rear-wheel Drive

    • MSRP:$10,977
    • Dealer Discount:$1,298
    • Market Price:$9,679
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    4.6L V-8 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    61,146 miles,
    MPG Range:
    17/25,
    Exterior Color:
    Red,
    Stock #:
    42456
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2017 Mitsubishi Mirage ES Hatchback Front-wheel Drive

    • Market Price:$9,997
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.2L I-3 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    41,114 miles,
    MPG Range:
    33/41,
    Exterior Color:
    Mystic Black,
    Stock #:
    42589
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2017 Mitsubishi Mirage ES Hatchback Front-wheel Drive

    • MSRP:$11,477
    • Dealer Discount:$1,480
    • Market Price:$9,997
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.2L I-3 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    44,144 miles,
    MPG Range:
    33/41,
    Exterior Color:
    Red,
    Stock #:
    42572
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2017 Mitsubishi Mirage G4 ES Sedan Front-wheel Drive

    • MSRP:$11,477
    • Dealer Discount:$1,480
    • Market Price:$9,997
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.2L I-3 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    40,035 miles,
    MPG Range:
    33/40,
    Exterior Color:
    Mercury Gray,
    Stock #:
    42571
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2017 Mitsubishi Mirage G4 ES Sedan Front-wheel Drive

    • Market Price:$9,997
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.2L I-3 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    40,396 miles,
    MPG Range:
    33/40,
    Exterior Color:
    Mercury Gray,
    Interior Color:
    Black,
    Stock #:
    42350
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • 2017 Mitsubishi Mirage G4 ES Sedan Front-wheel Drive

    • Market Price:$9,997
    • Check Availability
    Engine:
    1.2L I-3 cyl,
    Transmission:
    Automatic,
    Mileage:
    37,966 miles,
    MPG Range:
    33/40,
    Exterior Color:
    Mercury Gray,
    Interior Color:
    Black,
    Stock #:
    42447
    More
    • Carfax One Owner
  • Page 1 of 1

Middletown, Scotchtown, Newburgh & Monroe Drivers Know They're Getting a Good Deal

Each model is carefully inspected for safety and dependability. And the staff at Johnstons Toyota used car dealership has got you covered. Our finance department is happy to assist you with applying for financing and securing a loan.

Used cars are always inspected from the top to the bottom before they're traded into Johnstons Toyota used car dealership, which means you will always drive away with a safe and dependable vehicle. Another reason why previously owned cars are a good investment is simple. The biggest depreciation hit has already been taken. This is because a new car diminishes in value by 20-percent the minute it's driven off the lot, and another 10-percent is lost the first year someone owns it.

A used car is also a contender because drivers usually get more luxury features without spending as much money. This is because a base model of a new car will be more money than a used car from the bargain inventory segment. Your monthly insurance costs may also dwindle if you purchase a used vehicle. This is because it's worth can impact your monthly rate, and a used car costs less than a new vehicle, which means it will not be thought of as more valuable.

The best part is that once you decide on your next dream car, our certified automotive mechanics can help with routine maintenance like oil changes, tire rotations, and brake inspections. We want to make sure your next car is faithful, reliable and built to last.

Take a minute to browse our online inventory. If you find something you like, stop by Johnstons Toyota so one of our experienced sales associates can help you test-drive your next dream car. Then our finance specialists will walk you through the process, and you'll be on your way. We proudly serve drivers in Middletown, Goshen, Warwick, and beyond.


*The advertised price does not include sales tax, vehicle registration fees, finance charges, documentation charges ($75), and any other fees required by law. We attempt to update this inventory on a regular basis. However, there can be lag time between the sale of a vehicle and the update of the inventory.